After a spring hailstorm crosses Collin or Dallas County, a household ends up managing two things at once. One is the roof. The other is paper: a claim number scribbled on an envelope, photos spread across three phones, an email from the insurer that nobody can find a week later, a contractor's estimate in the glove box. The roof gets most of the attention, but it is the paper that decides how calm the following weeks will be. People who come through a roof claim without much strain are seldom experts in shingles or policies. They are the ones who can put a hand on the right page when someone asks for it.

That is all a claim file is. This guide walks through how to set one up, what goes into it at each stage, and where such files usually go wrong.

What the file is for

A roof claim is a long conversation among several parties who never sit in the same room: the homeowner, the insurer's claims desk, the adjuster who visits the house, a roofing contractor and, if there is a mortgage, sometimes the lender. Each of them sees a slice. The homeowner is the only one who sees all of it, and so the homeowner is the only one who can keep the whole record.

A good file does two jobs. It lets you answer a question the same way twice, because the answer is written down. And it shows what happened in what order, which matters when a call is remembered differently by the two people who were on it.

Set it up in ten minutes, before the first call

Use whatever you will really keep up with. A binder with dividers works. So does a single folder on a computer or in a cloud drive that both adults in the house can open. What matters is that there is one place and not four.

Inside it, make these sections:

  • Policy. The declarations page and the full policy, including any endorsements about the roof, wind or hail.
  • Dates and log. One running page of who said what and when.
  • Photos. The roof, the yard, the gutters, the ceilings, sorted by day.
  • Insurer. Every letter, email and document the insurance company sends, in the order received.
  • Contractor. Inspection notes, estimates, the contract, permit paperwork and invoices.
  • Money. Checks received, payments made, and receipts for anything spent on temporary protection.

Read the policy section first, before calling anyone. Look for the deductible that applies to wind and hail, which is often separate from the general one, and for any wording about how an older roof is valued. If something is unclear, write the question down and ask your agent. Check your policy for its own deadlines too, both for reporting damage and for finishing repairs, and copy them onto the first page of the log.

The date of loss

An insurer pays for damage from a particular event, so every roof claim is tied to a date of loss. In North Texas that is harder than it sounds. A single season can bring several storms over the same neighborhood, and hail is famously patchy: one street is hammered while the next gets rain.

Write the date at the top of the log, and under it write how you know. You were home and heard it. A doorbell camera recorded it. A neighbor's car was dented the same evening. Public storm reports from the National Weather Service can be looked up by anyone and show where hail and high wind were recorded on a given day. If you honestly cannot tell which storm did the damage, say that to the insurer in plain words. A guessed date that later turns out to be wrong creates more trouble than an honest "I am not sure, and here is why."

Photos that are still useful a month later

Most people take plenty of pictures and then cannot use them, because nobody remembers which slope a close-up shows. A little method fixes that.

From the ground, photograph each side of the house so the whole roof plane is visible, then the things hail marks first: gutters, downspouts, window screens, the air conditioner fins, the mailbox, fence tops, patio furniture. Indoors, photograph any ceiling stain with a wide shot that shows the room and a close shot that shows the stain. Stay off the roof yourself. A wet or damaged roof is a poor place for a homeowner, and a roofer's inspection photos will cover the surface.

Then name and sort them the same day. A folder per date, and file names that say where the picture was taken, are enough. The habit is the same one described in this publication's piece on sorting project photos before they pile up, and it pays off in exactly the same way: a picture you can find is evidence, and one you cannot find is clutter.

The running log

The log is the spine of the file. Every contact gets one line: the date, the person's name and role, how you spoke, and what was said or promised. Include the claim number in the first entry and the direct phone number or email of each person as you learn it.

Two habits make the log far more valuable. First, after any phone call that matters, send a short email to the person you spoke with: "Thank you for the call today. My understanding is that the adjuster will visit on Thursday morning." Now the conversation exists in writing. Second, note what you are waiting for and from whom. When a week passes in silence, the log tells you whose turn it is.

A roofer's inspection, and what to keep from it

Many homeowners have a roofing contractor look at the roof before, or soon after, they report a claim. The useful products of that visit are concrete: dated photos of each slope, close-ups of the damage with something for scale, pictures of the soft metal such as vents and flashing, and a plain statement of whether the roofer thinks the damage calls for a repair, a replacement or nothing at all. Ask for copies of all of it and put them in the contractor section.

It helps to be clear about roles. The claim belongs to the policyholder. A contractor can inspect, document, write an estimate for the work and show an adjuster what was found. Under Texas law a contractor may not act as a public adjuster, and may not pay, waive or rebate a deductible. If anyone offers either, write that in the log as well and treat it as a reason for caution.

The adjuster visit

The insurer's adjuster will come to look at the roof, usually by appointment. Put the appointment in the log, be home, and ask whether your roofer may attend so the adjuster can be shown the damage that was documented. That is a normal request.

During and right after the visit, write down:

  • the adjuster's name, company and contact details;
  • which slopes and which other items were examined, such as gutters, screens and the fence;
  • anything the adjuster said about what was or was not found;
  • what happens next and roughly when you should hear.

Do this the same afternoon, while it is fresh. The approach in our guide to writing down the details after a service visit applies word for word: a few lines made within the hour are worth more than a page reconstructed the following week.

Reading the two estimates side by side

Sooner or later the file will hold two documents that describe the same roof: the insurer's estimate and the contractor's. They are rarely identical, and the differences are usually ordinary ones. Lay them next to each other and go line by line. Is the roof area the same? Does each include tearing off the old material, new underlayment, drip edge, flashing, vents, and the gutters or screens that were marked? Is a city permit listed where your city requires one?

Circle every line that appears on one and not the other, and ask about each in writing. Your insurer can explain its own document, and a contractor can explain the construction reasons behind a line. For readers who find estimates hard going, our article on reading the details of a property service proposal covers the general skill.

The insurer's paperwork will also use terms that are worth understanding before any money moves, such as the difference between what is paid now and what may be paid after the work is finished. Verde Roofing, a Plano company, has published a plain account of how a roof insurance claim works, including which steps belong to the homeowner and which to a contractor. For anything specific to your coverage, the policy and your agent are the authority.

Payments and closing the file

In the money section, record each check: date, amount, who issued it and what the accompanying letter says it covers. If the mortgage company is named on a check, call the lender early and log what it requires, because that step can take time. Keep the signed contract, the permit record, the final invoice and proof of each payment you make. Keep the receipt for any emergency tarp or other temporary protection as well.

When the work is done, add the final photos, the warranty documents and the paid-in-full invoice, and write a closing line in the log with the date. Then keep the whole file with your house records. A future buyer, a future claim or a future roofer may all ask what was done to this roof and when.

Where claim files usually go wrong

The same few mistakes turn up again and again:

  • Starting the file after the confusion has already begun, and trying to rebuild the first two weeks from memory.
  • Relying on phone calls with no written follow-up.
  • Keeping photos only on one person's phone, unsorted.
  • Signing a contractor's document at the door without reading what it commits you to.
  • Throwing away envelopes and cover letters that carried dates.
  • Letting a deadline in the policy pass because nobody wrote it down.

When there is no claim at all

Not every storm leads to a claim. Sometimes an inspection finds nothing, or finds damage so minor that a small repair makes more sense than filing. That is a perfectly good outcome, and the folder is still worth keeping. Dated photos of a sound roof and a note that it was inspected after a named storm become the before picture for whatever comes next. In a part of Texas where hail is a regular visitor, an orderly record of the roof is less a claim file than a normal part of owning the house.

✳

A little context goes a long way.

About our editorial approach